Decoding Cigar Lingo: The Story Behind “Close, But No Cigar” & More
2 min read
SCigars have profoundly influenced our lifestyle and even the way we speak. Without realizing it, iconic phrases born from the world of cigars have woven themselves into our daily vocabulary. You’ve probably heard the saying “close, but no cigar,” but do you know its surprising origin? Let’s explore the history behind this famous phrase and uncover the stories behind other well-known cigar-related expressions.
The Origin of “Close, but no cigar”
This famous phrase refers to making an attempt at something but ultimately failing to achieve the desired outcome. Its origins trace back to the carnivals and fairgrounds of the 1920s United States.
Back then, cigars were common prizes awarded for winning carnival games, which were typically targeted at adults. These games were notoriously difficult to win. When a player narrowly missed winning, the stand owner would often shout the phrase “Close, but no cigar!” to signify their near-miss without a reward. As carnivals traveled across the country, so did the saying. While stuffed animals have largely replaced cigars as prizes today, the iconic phrase endures in our language.
Other Famous Cigar Sayings
Cigars have inspired more than just one common phrase. Here are a few others you might recognize:
This one is actually quite simple, despite its famous source: Sigmund Freud, the father of psychoanalysis known for finding deeper meanings. The saying suggests that not everything has a hidden psychological meaning; sometimes the simplest explanation is the true one. It’s believed this was Freud’s witty response to critics who overanalyzed his own cigar smoking habit.
While stories vary, the most common origin attributes this phrase to US Vice President Thomas Marshall. During a lengthy and tedious Senate debate where a senator repeatedly listed “what this country needs,” Marshall reportedly leaned over and quipped to a clerk, “What this country really needs is a good five-cent cigar.” The remark captured the public’s desire for simple, affordable pleasures and became widely popular.
Often taken out of context, this phrase can be misunderstood. It originates from the poem “The Betrothed” by Rudyard Kipling, which narrates the proceedings of a difficult choice. The stanza describes a man being asked to choose between his love interest and his beloved cigar, leading to this memorable, if perhaps cynical, response.
The Enduring Influence of Cigars
These sayings remind us of the deep cultural impact cigars have had over the centuries. They are more than just a smoke; they are woven into our history, language, and moments of reflection.If you wish to learn more about cigars or explore exclusive deals, sign up for our newsletter. Reach out to Cigar Country via their live chat or contact form.
